top of page
  • WellEvidenced

Why We Love to Jump to Conclusions: Cognitive Bias, Dissonance, and Emotional Maturity

Exploring the Psychological Pitfalls of Our Minds and How DBT Can Help.

Woman jumping into the air

Have you ever found yourself hastily jumping to conclusions or pigeonholing someone's personality on a fleeting first impression? In an era of relentless information and perpetual snap judgments, our minds often weave intricate webs of assumptions that hold us captive.

These mental shortcuts, or cognitive biases, may be subtle saboteurs, influencing our thinking, our relationships, and even our sense of self. Whether it's about that coworker who seems a little too friendly with the boss or the latest scandalous political headline, we're all guilty of forming opinions fast and hard.

So why we're so prone to doing this? In the following exploration, we'll venture into the mind's hidden alleys, unraveling the biases that guide us, often unknowingly. Let's take a look at what is going on in our brains when this happens and how cognitive biases and cognitive dissonance can keep us stuck in our ways.

Understanding these unconscious patterns can be a path to more enlightened living and support the development of emotional maturity. Let’s look at how DBT can help us outsmart our own brains.

CG illustration of human brain against a purple gradient

Cognitive Bias: How Your Brain Lies to You

Cognitive biases are mental shortcuts our brains use to process information more efficiently. While they can be helpful in some situations, these biases often lead to errors in judgment. For example, "confirmation bias" is when we seek out information that confirms our preexisting beliefs while ignoring contradictory evidence. An example:

Imagine you've recently adopted a low-carb diet, convinced that it's the optimal path to weight loss and overall health. You eagerly search for articles, studies, and testimonials that praise the benefits of this diet, ignoring or dismissing those that criticize it or highlight potential drawbacks. Every success story you find strengthens your belief that you've made the right choice, while any conflicting information is brushed aside as flawed or irrelevant. This focus on evidence that supports your view, coupled with a refusal to consider contradictory data, is a classic case of confirmation bias. It can shape not only our dietary decisions but also our views on politics, relationships, career choices, and much more, often without us even realizing it.

Cognitive Dissonance: When Our Beliefs and Actions Don't Mix

Cognitive dissonance is the uncomfortable feeling that arises when we hold contradictory beliefs or when our actions don't align with our values. Our brains don't like inconsistency, so we'll go to great lengths to reduce the discomfort by rationalizing our behavior or changing our beliefs. An example:

You strive to be eco-friendly in any way possible but can't resist buying a gas-heavy SUV. To reduce cognitive dissonance, you may tell yourself that you need the SUV for safety reasons, or that one car purchase won't really make a difference in the grand scheme of things. Problem solved, right? Well, not really.


Emotional Maturity: Growing Up Without Losing Our Sense of Humor

Emotional maturity is the ability to manage our emotions, empathize with others, and maintain healthy relationships. It's also closely related to cognitive biases and dissonance, as emotionally mature individuals are more likely to recognize and challenge these mental traps.

Basically, it's like being able to call yourself out on your own BS.

Here are 10 signs that may indicate a person has reached a level of emotional maturity:

Self-Awareness: Understanding one's emotions, strengths, weaknesses, and triggers. They reflect on their feelings and how they influence their behavior.

Empathy: The ability to understand and share the feelings of others, showing compassion and consideration without judgment.

Responsibility: Taking ownership of one's actions and their consequences, whether positive or negative. This includes apologizing and making amends when necessary.

Resilience: Facing setbacks with strength and perseverance, learning from them, and moving forward without being unduly discouraged.

Effective Communication: Expressing oneself clearly and respectfully, even in disagreements. They listen actively and validate others' feelings.

Flexibility: Adapting to change and accepting that plans and people may evolve. They don't stubbornly cling to one viewpoint or expectation.

Healthy Boundaries: Recognizing and setting appropriate personal limits, respecting the boundaries of others, and communicating these clearly.

Emotional Regulation: Managing and controlling intense emotions without denying or suppressing them. They don't allow temporary feelings to result in impulsive or destructive behaviors.

Conflict Resolution: Approaching conflicts with a goal of understanding and collaboration rather than victory. They can disagree without being disagreeable.

Humility and Open-Mindedness: Acknowledging that they don't have all the answers and are open to learning from others. They recognize and appreciate the value in different perspectives.

Individuals exhibiting these traits are generally considered to be emotionally mature, leading to more fulfilling and balanced relationships with themselves and others.

Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT): Embracing Both Sides

DBT is a therapeutic approach that combines cognitive-behavioral techniques with mindfulness practices. It helps people accept and validate their emotions while also learning to change unhelpful patterns of thinking and behavior. For example, DBT encourages us to replace "but" with "and" in our thoughts, as in, "I can love my parents and disagree with their politics." This helps us embrace the gray area and avoid jumping to conclusions.

Here are five thought exercises or techniques that utilize DBT principles to examine or avoid cognitive biases:

  1. Wise Mind Exercise: Encourage mindfulness by pausing and assessing your thoughts before reacting. Ask yourself, "Is this thought based on facts or emotions?" Engage the Wise Mind (a balanced integration of rational thinking and emotional feeling) to discern between the two.

  2. Pros and Cons List: When faced with a decision or forming an opinion, write a pros and cons list. This exercise encourages a more balanced and non-judgmental assessment of the situation, helping to avoid one-sided thinking or confirmation bias.

  3. "And" not "But" Technique: (As you've mentioned) Replace "but" with "and" in your thoughts and statements. This allows for a more complex view of the situation, recognizing that conflicting realities can exist simultaneously. For example, instead of saying, "I want to go out, but I need to work," say, "I want to go out, and I need to work."

  4. Opposite Action Technique: If you recognize that a cognitive bias is influencing your reaction to a situation (e.g., catastrophizing or black-and-white thinking), deliberately act in a way that is opposite to the emotion driving the bias. For instance, if fear is causing you to avoid a situation, approach it slowly and methodically instead, examining the actual evidence for your fear.

  5. Check the Facts Exercise: When you find yourself making broad or biased statements, actively engage in a fact-checking exercise. Ask yourself, "What's the evidence for and against this belief?" and "Is this an opinion or a fact?" By doing so, you can counter cognitive biases like overgeneralization or jumping to conclusions.

These exercises help create a more mindful and balanced approach to thinking, enabling a more nuanced understanding of situations and reducing the influence of cognitive biases. Utilizing them in daily life can foster greater clarity and emotional regulation.

By recognizing and challenging cognitive biases and dissonance, and developing emotional maturity, we can learn to embrace the complexities of life instead of leaping to conclusions. And with the help of DBT, we can become thought ninjas, skillfully navigating the world of conflicting ideas without losing our fabulous sense of humor.


bottom of page